Ipsos Tracker: Retail Discounts Shift in 2026

Listen to this article · 11 min listen

The latest Ipsos Consumer Tracker data confirms what we’re seeing on the ground: the old assumption that online promotions always win is dead. Shopper expectations are far more complicated now, and if you don’t get your discount strategy right between online and in-store, your conversion rates and loyalty are going to suffer. Getting a handle on these changing expectations directly impacts your bottom line. So the big question we’re all wrestling with for 2026 is how to properly balance online and in-store discounts to actually make more money.

Key Takeaways

  • Stop guessing and dig into your actual customer data on platforms like Shopify Analytics or Adobe Commerce to see which discount channels YOUR customers prefer, because general trends don’t apply to every niche.
  • Set up geo-fencing to hit customers with in-store exclusive deals when they’re close by (think a 5-mile radius), pushing SMS or app notifications with tools like Swirl or Local Logic.
  • Run A/B tests on your site using Optimizely or a Google Optimize alternative to see what actually works better for your audience, is it percentage-off or a flat dollar-off?
  • Make your loyalty program work everywhere by integrating your CRM like Salesforce or HubSpot so points earned in-store can be spent online, and vice-versa, without any friction.
  • Use tools like SpyFu or SEMrush to see what your competitors are up to with their discounts, identify where they’re weak, and adjust your own promotional calendar every quarter to exploit those gaps.

1. Segment Your Audience and Analyze Behavioral Data

You can’t launch a single discount without first knowing who you’re talking to and where they’re listening. This isn’t guesswork. It’s digging into your data. For any e-commerce operation, that means getting your hands dirty in Shopify Analytics, Adobe Commerce Intelligence, or even GA4 reports. You’re looking for real patterns. Do people click on discount banners or do they convert from email offers? For brick-and-mortar folks, your POS data from systems like Lightspeed Retail POS or Toast POS is gold. Track which specific discounts are bringing people through the door and which ones are actually increasing the average ticket size.

Pro Tip: Don’t get fixated on conversion rates alone. You need to look at the customer lifetime value (CLTV) of the people you acquire from different discount channels. We’ve found that a customer who comes in for an in-store only deal might end up having a much higher CLTV because they become a regular, even if that initial online flash sale had a technically “better” conversion rate.

Common Mistake: Looking only at top-line sales numbers during a promo. A big sales spike doesn’t mean your discount strategy worked. You have to break down that data by customer segment, purchase history, and channel to see what really happened. A 20% off online coupon will pull in a completely different type of customer than an in-store “buy one, get one free” offer, and you need to know who is who.

2. Implement Geo-Fencing for Hyper-Local In-Store Offers

The real power of in-store discounts in 2026 is their ability to generate immediate foot traffic from people who are right there. With geo-fencing technology, you can hit potential customers’ phones the second they get physically close to your store. Platforms like Swirl or Local Logic let you draw a virtual perimeter around your physical shop. When a customer who has your app installed (with location services on, of course) steps inside that zone, they get a push notification with an offer. Think about a shopper walking through Midtown Atlanta. Their phone buzzes with “15% off any full-priced item, in-store only, good for the next two hours.” That’s a direct and powerful reason to walk in.

Setting this up is straightforward. You go into the geo-fencing platform, plug in your store’s GPS coordinates, and define a radius, maybe half a mile or a mile. Then you write a compelling, time-sensitive offer. For example, if you run a coffee shop near the Five Points MARTA station, you could push a “free pastry with any coffee purchase” alert that’s only active between 7 AM and 9 AM to people in that zone. This is how you drive impulse buys.

3. A/B Test Online Discount Formats and Messaging

Your online store has tons of discount options, but they absolutely do not perform the same. A/B testing is the only way to figure out what your digital audience actually responds to. Using tools like Optimizely Web Experimentation (or a replacement for the now-sunsetted Google Optimize) you can create two versions of a promotion to see what sticks. For instance, you could test:

  • Variant A: “20% Off All Orders Over $75”
  • Variant B: “Save $15 on All Orders Over $75”

You run these tests at the same time on a slice of your web traffic and watch the metrics like a hawk: click-throughs, conversions, and average order value. The data will tell you in black and white which format works better for certain products. Remember the rule of thumb: a percentage discount usually looks bigger on high-ticket items, while a fixed dollar amount can feel more attractive for cheaper goods.

Pro Tip: Test your urgency copy, too. We’ve seen conversion rate swings of 5-7% just by changing the phrasing from something generic like “Limited Time Offer” to something specific and concrete like “Ends Sunday at Midnight.” The words you use can be just as important as the numbers.

4. Integrate Loyalty Programs Across All Channels

Customers don’t see a hard line between your website and your physical store, so why should your discount strategy have one? A unified loyalty program is the best way to connect the two worlds. A customer should be able to earn points from an online purchase and then use those points for a discount when they walk into your shop, and the other way around. This is what platforms like Salesforce Loyalty Management or the loyalty functions in HubSpot Service Hub are built for. When someone scans their digital loyalty card in your store, the cashier should see their online purchase history and available rewards right there on the screen. And when they log in to your website, the points they earned last week visiting your Peachtree Street location should be ready to use.

This creates a single, continuous experience that encourages people to keep coming back, no matter which channel they use. Someone might earn double points buying a new gadget from you online, then use those points to get a discount on accessories when they pop into your store later that week. This cross-channel reward system is what builds real brand loyalty and increases what a customer spends over their lifetime.

5. Monitor Competitor Strategies and Market Trends

Your discount strategy isn’t created in a bubble. You have to constantly watch what your competitors are doing, both online and in their stores. Tools like SpyFu or the competitive research parts of SEMrush can show you their ad spend, what discount-related keywords they’re bidding on, and even their past promotions. For their physical stores, it means doing old-fashioned recon: go to their locations, get on their email lists, and check out the local mailers. Are they running a deeper discount online than in-store? Do they have in-store events with special pricing? What can you learn?

And it’s not just about direct competitors. Look at the bigger picture. An eMarketer report from late 2025 found that nearly 60% of consumers now expect personalized offers no matter where they shop. This is a clear signal to move away from one-size-fits-all discounts and toward promotions driven by data. You should be re-evaluating your strategy every quarter based on this intelligence. If a competitor launches a successful “buy online, pick up in-store” (BOPIS) offer with an extra discount attached, you have to seriously consider if that’s something that would work for you. Don’t just copy them, but understand which way the wind is blowing.

Common Mistake: Discounting so often or so deeply that you trash your own brand’s value. Yes, discounts drive sales, but if you’re constantly running a sale, you’re just training your customers to wait for one. It’s a race to the bottom that a lot of smaller businesses fall into when they feel pressure from big-box stores. Sometimes a smaller, smarter, well-timed discount is much more profitable.

6. Use Social Media for Exclusive Flash Sales

Social media isn’t just for posting nice photos anymore. It’s a direct sales machine, especially for quick, urgent discounts. With features like Instagram Shopping and TikTok Shop, you can tag products and let people buy right in the app, which is perfect for a flash sale. Announce a deal that’s only good for a very short time, like a “24-hour only” offer you push through an Instagram Story or a TikTok Live. This creates real urgency and pushes immediate sales. To track what’s working, you can even create unique discount codes for each platform, like “INSTA20” or “TIKTOK15”, so you can see exactly where your sales are coming from.

Get interactive with it. Run a poll on an Instagram Story and let your followers vote on which product gets the next discount. Or use TikTok’s Q&A feature during a live broadcast to answer questions about a product right before you drop a surprise discount code. This makes your followers feel like they’re part of a community, which gets them more engaged and much more likely to buy when you do offer a deal. The whole point is to make these social media discounts feel like an exclusive inside track for your followers.

Pro Tip: Work with micro-influencers on these flash sales. Their followers trust them, and a genuine recommendation paired with a unique discount code can drive a surprising amount of traffic and sales. It adds a layer of social proof you can’t get on your own.

Getting the balance right between online and in-store discounts means being obsessed with your data, testing everything, and keeping a close watch on your customers and your competitors. If you segment your audience correctly, use location-based tech, integrate your loyalty programs, and get smart with social media, you can build a discount strategy for 2026 that actually grows your revenue and creates customers who stick around.

How often should I change my discount strategy?

Your strategy needs to be alive. I’d look at the performance data every month for small tweaks, but plan on doing a full strategic review each quarter. Things like competitor moves, market shifts, and your own sales targets change too fast to just set it and forget it. You have to be agile.

Are percentage-off or dollar-off discounts more effective?

It really depends on the price of your product. For cheaper stuff (say, under $100), a dollar-off amount usually feels more real to people, “$10 off” sounds better than “10% off” on a $50 shirt. For expensive items, a percentage-off discount looks bigger, since “20% off” a $500 product is an obvious $100 in savings. The only way to know for sure what works for your audience is to A/B test it.

How can I prevent customers from only buying discounted items?

That’s the constant battle. Try to focus on promotions that add value instead of just slashing prices. Think “buy one, get one free” on related items, offering free shipping once they hit a certain cart value, or giving loyalty members early access to new products. You also have to limit your big sales so they feel like a real event, not just business as usual.

Should online and in-store discounts always be the same?

Not at all. There are good strategic reasons to have different offers. You can use an online-only discount to drive traffic to your website or clear out old inventory. An in-store exclusive is perfect for getting people in the door and encouraging them to buy other things they see. As long as you have a clear reason for the difference, it’s a smart tactic.

What is the role of personalization in discount strategies?

It’s everything. Sending a discount based on someone’s actual behavior, like their purchase history or something they looked at but didn’t buy, is way more effective than a generic blast. An offer for a product they’ve already shown interest in, or even just a simple birthday discount, feels personal and is much more likely to get them to buy.

Editorial Team

The Editorial Team at CMO News Desk is a group of writers and editors who cover marketing, brand, and growth. They research each story and publish under a shared desk byline — experts in their fields, working as one team.