Key Takeaways
- You can’t just dabble in retail media. It demands a dedicated budget, as our $75,000 spend over six weeks proved.
- Using a retailer’s first-party data (think loyalty programs and purchase history) to segment audiences is what actually makes conversion rates go up.
- Your creative has to be built for each specific ad placement, what works in search won’t work on a category page, so you have to connect the product benefits to that part of the shopper’s journey.
- Just running consistent A/B tests on your ad copy and images can give you a 15% bump in CTR during a single campaign.
- Pairing influencer marketing with your retail media ads gives you a shot of authenticity and reach, which you can see in the sales numbers.
Retail media networks have totally changed how consumer brands have to think about digital advertising. These aren’t some side channel anymore. They’re built on a mountain of first-party shopper data, giving you a sharp way to reach people right when they’re about to buy. But the real question is, can you actually turn that potential into sales? We put it to the test with a six-week campaign for a new premium pet food on a big grocery network to see if we could drive both awareness and immediate purchases.
Campaign Overview: Launching “Wholesome Bites”
Our goal was pretty simple: get “Wholesome Bites,” a new grain-free dog food, in front of pet owners who were already engaged and drive sales straight through the retailer’s e-commerce site. We set aside a $75,000 budget for a six-week run from late April to early June 2026, which had to cover all our media spend, creative work, and platform fees. We were watching our Cost Per Lead (CPL), Return on Ad Spend (ROAS), Click-Through Rate (CTR), impressions, conversions, and cost per conversion like hawks.
Strategy: Using First-Party Data for Precision
Our whole strategy was built on using the retailer’s own first-party data. We weren’t just buying impressions. We were buying direct access to what people intended to purchase.
Targeting Segments: We broke our audience down into three main groups:
- Existing Pet Food Buyers: These were customers who’d bought premium dog food from this specific retailer in the past 90 days. We got even more specific, filtering out anyone who only bought competing brands that contained grain.
- New Pet Owners: We found these shoppers by looking for recent purchases of puppy supplies, dog beds, or even pet insurance through the store’s affiliate programs.
- Health-Conscious Shoppers: This was our wildcard segment. We targeted people who regularly bought organic produce, natural supplements, or other specialty diet foods, betting they might apply that same health-first mindset to their pets.
Placement Strategy: We didn’t put all our eggs in one basket. We hit the network from multiple angles:
- Sponsored Product Ads: We made sure we showed up at the top of search results for keywords like “grain-free dog food,” “premium puppy food,” and “hypoallergenic dog food.”
- Display Ads on Category Pages: We put banners on the main pet food aisle page and in related sub-categories like “dog treats” and “pet supplies.”
- Off-Site Programmatic Display: Here, we used the retailer’s data to find their customers on other websites and apps, trying to pull them back to our product page.
- Email Integration: We managed to get a few spots in the retailer’s weekly promo emails sent to the most relevant customer groups.
Creative Approach: Emphasizing Health and Trust
Our creative hammered on two points: the health upside of a grain-free diet and the natural ingredients in Wholesome Bites. We made different creative for every type of placement.
- Sponsored Product Ads: These were all about high-res product shots with short, punchy headlines like “Grain-Free Goodness for Happy Pups” or “Boost Digestion, Boost Joy.” We ran A/B tests pitting price call-outs against these benefit-focused lines.
- Display Ads: For these, we used lifestyle shots of active, healthy-looking dogs with their Wholesome Bites, sometimes with a person in the frame. The copy called out ingredients like “real salmon” and “garden vegetables” and had a direct call to action (CTA) like “Shop Now.” For the off-site ads, we even used a short video showing the kibble texture and how dogs went for it.
- Email Banners: We kept these clean, a strong product shot, one headline (“Unlock Your Dog’s Best Health”), and a link straight to the product page.
A critical piece we added was user-generated content (UGC) from a micro-influencer campaign. We found pet influencers who actually liked the product and had them create unboxing videos and clips of them feeding it to their dogs. We then repurposed that content in some of our display ads which gave them a layer of realness that stock photos can never have. This is exactly the kind of situation where a specialized mobile marketing agency like Moburst proves its worth. Their expertise in Influencer Marketing makes sure you connect with the right people and can weave their content into your main strategy. Having their dedicated team handle the vetting, negotiation, and tracking for us meant our own people could stay focused on the rest of the campaign.
Campaign Performance: What Worked and What Didn’t
The results were a mixed bag, but we learned a ton for the next time we invest in retail media.
Key Metrics Snapshot (Six Weeks)
- Total Budget: $75,000
- Impressions: 7.8 million
- Clicks: 112,000
- CTR: 1.44%
- Conversions (Purchases): 2,800
- Conversion Rate: 2.5%
- Cost Per Conversion: $26.79
- Average Order Value (AOV): $45.00
- ROAS: 1.68x
Analysis of Performance by Segment and Placement
Segment Performance
As you’d expect, the Existing Pet Food Buyers segment was our star performer. This group gave us a 3.1% conversion rate and a 2.1x ROAS. It’s clear proof that targeting people who are already in the market for your category is the fastest path to a return. Our CPL for this group was a manageable $18.50.
The New Pet Owners group had potential, but they needed more convincing. Their conversion rate was 1.9% with a 1.2x ROAS. The cost per conversion jumped to $35.00, telling us we should have been educating them more instead of just going for the hard sell. We saw that creative focused on “first-year nutrition” did better with them.
Our Health-Conscious Shoppers segment was the weakest part of the plan, delivering a 0.8% conversion rate and a dismal 0.7x ROAS. At a CPL of $65.00, it just wasn’t sustainable. The theory was good, but getting someone to jump from thinking about their own organic food to their pet’s food was too big a leap for a direct-response ad. That audience clearly needed a much longer, brand-focused awareness campaign first.
Placement Performance
Sponsored Product Ads did most of the heavy lifting, driving 60% of our total conversions. With a 3.2% CTR and a 2.5x ROAS, their power is obvious, they put you right there at the moment someone is searching for what you sell. Our A/B test also found that a headline with a sense of urgency (like “Save 15% Today”) beat a benefit-only headline by 12% in CTR.
Display Ads on Category Pages did alright, bringing in 25% of conversions with a 0.9% CTR and a 1.4x ROAS. The trick was to look like we belonged there while also being different enough to get noticed. The display ads that used influencer UGC got 20% more engagement than the ones with our professional product shots.
Off-Site Programmatic Display was a tough sell for direct conversions, kicking in only 10% of our total purchases. It got us a lot of impressions (4 million), but the CTR was a low 0.4% and the ROAS was just 0.8x. This channel was much better for top-of-funnel awareness than for immediate sales, especially for what it cost. Its real value came from retargeting people who’d already visited our product page.
Email Integration was a small part of the plan but punched way above its weight, giving us 5% of our conversions with a huge 5.5% CTR and a 3.0x ROAS. This just shows how powerful it is to talk directly to an engaged audience. The hard part is figuring out how to do more of it without burning out the retailer’s valuable email list.
What Worked Well
- Hyper-Specific Targeting: Going after existing pet food buyers was the most efficient money we spent.
- Sponsored Product Ads: Being right in the search results is the best place to be for quick sales.
- Real Creative: Using influencer content in our display ads made a noticeable difference in engagement.
- Email Placements: They performed amazingly well, but you can’t build a whole strategy on them.
What Didn’t Work as Expected
- Broad “Health” Targeting: That segment needed a totally different, more educational approach and a much longer customer journey.
- Off-Site Ads for Sales: It was good for getting our name out there, but it didn’t drive sales directly. It felt more like a branding play.
- Vague CTAs on Display: We learned that specific calls to action like “Shop Grain-Free” did better than a generic “Shop Now.”
Optimization Steps Taken and Learnings
We were making changes on the fly for the entire six weeks.
- Budget Reallocation: After two weeks, we saw the writing on the wall. We moved 20% of the budget away from the failing “Health-Conscious Shoppers” segment and put it on our winner, “Existing Pet Food Buyers,” while also upping our spend on sponsored product ads by 15%.
- Creative Refresh: We wrote new copy for the “New Pet Owners” group that talked more about nutrition for puppies. On the display side, we started rotating in more of the influencer content and tested visuals with different dog breeds.
- Negative Keyword Implementation: We were constantly checking the search terms that triggered our sponsored ads and adding negative keywords like “cheap dog food” to stop wasting money on the wrong clicks.
- Landing Page Optimization: Working with the retailer, we made sure our product page was crystal clear about the benefits, showed customer reviews, and had a big, obvious “add to cart” button, which we think boosted our on-page conversion rate by about 8% from ad traffic.
- Retargeting Adjustment: We built a special retargeting audience of people who looked at the Wholesome Bites page but didn’t buy, then hit them with a small discount offer in our off-site ads. That little tweak lifted the conversion rate for that specific group by 1.5%.
The main takeaway is that retail media isn’t a “set it and forget it” channel. A ROAS of 1.68x isn’t something to brag about, but the real value was in the lessons we learned for optimizing the next campaign. For a new product launch, you need a mix of direct-response ads (like sponsored products) and brand-building awareness (like off-site display), and you have to be ready to shift your budget based on what’s actually working.
Conclusion
If you’re going to play in the retail media sandbox, you have to be nimble and willing to change your strategy based on what the data is telling you every day. You can’t just buy impressions anymore. You have to build targeted messages that connect with where a shopper is, mentally, in their buying process. Your success in this crowded space comes down to how well you can use the retailer’s first-party data and adapt your creative on the fly. CMOs who are demanding ROI have to get their heads around these new dynamics. It’s also pretty clear that having accurate AI attribution is the only way you’ll ever truly understand what parts of a messy campaign like this are actually working.
So what is a retail media network?
It’s basically an ad platform that a retailer builds so brands can advertise directly on their websites and apps. They let you use the store’s own shopper data (what people buy, when, etc.) to target your ads. Think Amazon Ads, Walmart Connect, or Kroger Precision Marketing.
How does first-party data actually help?
First-party data is the goldmine. It’s all the information the retailer collects themselves from sales and loyalty programs, purchase history, what someone browsed, basic demographics. It lets you stop guessing and start targeting people with ads for things they’re very likely to be interested in, which makes them much more likely to convert.
What kinds of ads can you run on these networks?
The most common types are sponsored product ads that show up in search results, display ads (banners) on category or product pages, and sponsored brand ads that promote your whole product line. Some also let you use their data to retarget their customers on other websites and apps.
How do you know if a retail media campaign is working?
You measure it with standard metrics like Return on Ad Spend (ROAS), conversion rates, and Cost Per Acquisition (CPA). But you also look at things like incremental sales lift, did you sell more than you would have without the ads? The platforms usually have good reporting that connects ad views directly to purchases made on their site.
What are the biggest headaches for CMOs using these networks?
The main challenges for CMOs are trying to manage data from a bunch of different retailers at once, keeping the brand message consistent, and figuring out attribution when a customer sees five different ads before buying. Justifying the budget and proving the ads are generating new sales (not just capturing ones you’d get anyway) are also huge hurdles.